The Cause and Prevention of Neuroses
Dr. Alfred Adler, Vienna
You are rightly expecting me to set before you what is perhaps a novel point of view, and I may define my attitude by giving you as an alternative title, "The Feeling of Inferiority and Its Consequences". To me it appears that every child and every human being, for some reason, is continually striving to answer questions, to overcome difficulties, to solve riddles, and to develop himself in some degree towards a self-satisfying completion, the full achievement of his life purpose. No matter what may be the age of an individual, you will find tendencies which have their beginnings—if one may venture to use the phrase—in the dawn of life, and which, by their persistence, ever demand a development to a higher level. Such tendencies can only exist if there be a goal, and I will endeavor to put before you what, to my mind, this must be.
In the face of reality, we must always define our position and form a conception of our relationship to our environment, which conception involves and determines our standards of behavior, our attitudes and our demands. Whatever is revealed in the character of a human being, there is always manifested this persistent demand for greater development and a continual striving for the achievement of a certain goal. One may instance the wish of a child to become a coachman, or that of an adult to become a physician or a judge. In every walk of life, in every situation where the problems of living are being attacked, there is to be observed this striving for superiority, this striving for power; and you can properly understand the particular reaction of the moment only if you realize the existence of this fundamental undercurrent. A symptom can only properly be distinguished and recognized when it is defined as an incidental object in the general current of the striving towards a goal of superiority.
The goal of a normal man is easily appreciated, and we can realize that he has, in the main, three great problems to solve. The first of these is the ambition to mix with, and be accepted by others. This is the problem of social relationships, the desire for fellowship, to take some place in the world of men. The approach to other men takes devious routes, but if we fail to find the actual social ideal of any one individual, we can yet judge by how much he falls short of the normal achievement in regard to this first question of life. For example, he may have no friends, or he may not interest himself in societies or in social functions, or he may have a positive distaste for companionship. You can, in this way, measure approximately the failure of achievement in this direction, and it is noteworthy that in the case of the neurotic, the degree of failure is usually very marked. So, as you can imagine, he must have another goal, and, in consequence, he is always trying to escape from the right, the normal aim of social life.
The second problem which is always before us, and which cannot be avoided without increasing the difficulty of solution of the first, is that of occupation, and the two are not wholly separated. The problem of occupation resolves itself literally as "How can I be useful for the whole of mankind?" Every occupation, so-called, is a beginning of this trying to be useful, to live on the useful side. To be useful induces a feeling of great confidence and well-being, and the person who feels useless is always more or less shy, he feels himself isolated, and finds great difficulty in carrying out his work. As I have already remarked, this leads us to suspect the presence of another goal.
The third problem of life is that of sex. People live together in two sexes, and so an aim with everyone is to unite with someone of the opposite sex as a partner. This solution is the normal one; it is the normal goal for everybody. The degree of failure of achievement of this natural solution will always betray to what extent the problem is being evaded.
If you ask what reason there can be for such an evasion, I reply that throughout the whole world there is one reason for it: it is a lack of self-confidence, a lack of courage; in the mind of the individual concerned there is the idea that he cannot reach this goal. You will realize this if you consider your experience of neurotic subjects. The question at once arises as to how it has happened that some people—many people—have such a fear, so much so that they are averse to trying to solve this problem in the natural way.
I come from work in the pathological field, and in connection with psychological questions I have always noted that one of the most important reasons for such a lack of courage is the existence of an organic burden in childhood. Delicate children differ very much from the healthy in their view of the world, because they suffer from organic deficiencies and defects; they do not eat and assimilate as easily, they cannot see or hear so well, they have troubles due to abnormalities of the endocrine glands. To such children the world is a great difficulty, an embarrassing problem, yet in the first years of their life they must arrive at some answer. The attention the child has to give in his little life to the world shapes for him his style of life. He experiences the difficulties and the burdens of his own body, and these make a great impression on him. The investigation of the adult life of such children convinces me that these burdens are remembered. I hope I may succeed in presenting the matter so that you may see how the whole attitude throughout life is based on what takes place and what is the equipment in childhood, in short, on this feeling of personal inferiority, and that in the case of children burdened with physical defects and deficiencies it is greatly intensified. We have to remember that these defects, in many cases, are inherited, and, therefore, there arises the question of the relation of inherited defects to the development of the character. However, the character is not everything. Even the normal child suffers in a difficult situation, and if he has disturbances of vision or hearing, or some similar disability, he feels he cannot bear it. In all cases there is a relationship between the child's defects and the particular problems that confront him in life.
I have come to another conclusion also. In considering the lives of children in general, it appears to me that there are two situations which are peculiarly inimical to normal development. One of these arises where the child is made to face greater difficulties, in which case there is a greater feeling of inferiority. The other is concerned with the process of "spoiling", for then the child is much worse than before. Such a child is always leaning on another person. He lives in a symbiotic manner, like a parasite, and he receives everything from others. As a consequence he cannot develop a normal style of life, for he is always demanding and receiving, and he never feels the necessity for using his own powers. If a child, or an adult, never attempts to stand alone, he always lacks confidence and courage, and we are justified in regarding such spoiled children as not properly prepared to meet the constantly changing situations of life.
If you inquire into the goal of such children, i.e., those with organic deficiencies, or those who have been spoiled, you will find that their aim is to overcome the difficulties of life in the most complete fashion. They are not satisfied with that to which the normal child aspires; for them there must be no less than the complete command of the situation, an absolute security, and their demands upon others are unlimited. You will agree that this is a habit, or an attitude, which does not make for happiness in our life upon this earth. If you ask your nervous patients you will find, very often, that they have begun in such a way, as spoiled children, and the two types I have mentioned are very often connected. Sometimes it is impossible to educate the delicate child without spoiling it, and better methods are needed.
As a rule, the custom is that, as regards education, no distinction is made between the abnormal and the normal child who has the normal goal, which is to mix with others, to be useful, to give and not always to receive and to demand. For the abnormal as well as for the normal child, however, new situations must continually arise. With every change the child, as it were, makes an experiment in adaptation, and it is obvious to the observer, as it no doubt is to the child, that the experiments are mainly unsuccessful, for children such as we have in mind are not capable of independence, of working with others for a common usefulness. As a consequence, the abnormal child will always be torn with conflicts.
I may describe a third type, the hated child, the child who grows up without warmth and love, very often illegitimate, or at any rate unwanted, and it will be apparent to you that for such a child the world is to a great extent comparable to an enemy country. He meets with nothing but enmity; kindness and love are unknown to him, and he experiences nothing but insult and attack. It follows that children of this type develop what may be termed a defensive attitude; they have no desire to join in with the efforts of others, and they have no wish to be useful in a hostile community. Thus, they also are always in a situation of conflict.
The general reactions of the third type are the same as those of the first and second; they are unhappy in school, in work, and in love, and they always feel restricted. The only satisfaction for them is to be superior to every other man, to conquer, to be the first, to be God-like in their power and domination. They have no patience, opposition irritates them, and they feel that by any means they must defend themselves, justify themselves morally, and shine in the highest sphere. To accomplish this they adopt the only possible course of restricting their environment, for they cannot hold complete sway in the whole of society, where they feel that their efforts are being curtailed. They evade occupation, and they evade love; their eccentricities are always signs of evasion, but those signs, or we may say symptoms, of the attempt to escape the solution of the three questions of life are not always obvious, for patients as well as others will justify their attitude to themselves by rationalizations. I have never met a man who frankly said, "I do not want to mix with others", but I have met many people who told me, "I cannot go into society because the people are so bad; the people around me cannot appreciate me, and they are distasteful". I have never seen such a man frankly avoiding occupation; he will only say, "I am tired, I cannot sleep, I have a headache", or "I have symptoms which hinder me from making up my mind in this matter". Another will say, "This occupation is not good enough for me; I must have something better; I have not a good memory", and so on, while another may say, "I cannot concentrate". There are always justifications for evasions, but we physicians know there are no real reasons for such symptoms.
Now I should like to say a few words about the appearance of symptoms. Symptoms do not arise suddenly in a night. There is always a long period of development which can be traced back, often to childhood, and I have found that the history of the case invariably indicates such antecedent situations as we have considered in the three types of children. For instance, the spoiled child will always tend to cling to the individual who spoils him; as a rule this is the mother, and commonly these tendencies are apparently prompted by anxiety. With nervous people this symptom is always in the foreground, for they are always attempting to justify the carrying out of their wishes to command other persons on the grounds of their anxiety. People who cannot be alone, who have agoraphobia, command and require that another person shall be with them, and this other person must obey—his life must be ruled and ordered by the patient. If the neurotic person has a headache, all the family must be silent, must obey, must take care not to irritate. There is constantly this striving for superiority and for domination by any means, however petty, and we can understand some of these symptoms, because they are nurtured and developed in childhood. In some cases the symptoms derive from a condition of emotional tension, and to thwart such a patient induces an almost inconceivable reaction of depression, even to the extent that there may be an attempt at suicide. Even in their play such individuals are very deeply moved emotionally, and it is only by realizing their life aims that we can appreciate the subjective disturbance.
The foregoing is a short description of the tendencies among nervous persons. In every single reaction you can recognize the attitude to life if you have previously grasped the distortion of the personality. I am in agreement with the whole current of medicine only when I insist that we cannot treat symptoms; we can but treat the individual, and, in this matter, to be of any help you must change the attitude to life of the whole individual. So long as the patient persists in his morbid attitude, you cannot get rid of the symptoms. It is not sufficient to treat the consequences of a fault; we must go deeper, and perhaps I can show you, by relating one or two cases, what I mean.
I will cite the case of a young woman, twenty-six years of age, in good bodily health, who has been suffering considerably for about a year with agoraphobia and depression. She dated the onset of her trouble as a year ago in time, but, as is usual, on inquiring more fully I found that the symptoms really originated in a change of her life situation. When I asked this young woman what had happened a year before, she said that she had then become a mother for the first time. The connection is not at once obvious, but it is very clear that such an event is full of possibilities in the hands of a spoilt person. Such an individual always aspires to be the center of attention; the coming of the child of her own makes the difficulty the greater for her, and sometimes neurotic symptoms will commence from the time of the first confinement.
In this case, however, that was not all. When I hinted at the point, she told me this story: "I like my husband very much, and he likes me also. He went away to Paris three days after my confinement. He amused himself there, and I have intended going to Paris in spite of him. I was very angry." Another point was that this woman had, as very often happens, a very annoying and foolish mother-in-law. She was a very critical woman, and the young wife was the spoilt child, the only child of very weak parents, who could not tolerate this new situation. She often cried and became very angry when her husband showed a disposition to differ with her. They frequently quarreled in spite of the love they had for each other. It appeared to me that when the child came, and the husband went off to Paris, she felt that the time had come to reinforce her own position. She no longer felt herself to be in command, to be the first and most important person and first in her husband's love. The husband loved the child very much, and took a great interest in it, while she became more and more irritable and also very depressed. It was clear to me that what she did then was a repetition of what she had done in her childhood: she aimed at being the center of attention, and if she were displaced, then she developed anxieties, so she suffered from an anxious depression and forced the husband to be with her always—an indication which enables us to understand her actions. She could not go on a tram, and she could not travel by train, but she could drive in a car. The point of that is easily seen if one bears in mind the underlying aim. In the train or in the tram the passenger is one of many: definite stopping places are arranged and individual rights must be subordinated to the rules laid down, but with a private car the stopping and the route can be controlled, therefore people constituted like our patient always feel they can travel by car. This little characteristic is typical of the whole attitude to life. There is the feeling of superiority, the God-likeness, the desire to dominate, to be always first. Such signs should always be carefully noted, they are very informative, and indicate clearly in what direction the general attitude of the patient is tending.
This woman came into the sanatorium, which is often in itself an extenuating situation, because to be in a sanatorium is to command much weight of sympathy. The whole family is probably much more amenable when one is in a sanatorium. While she was there our patient improved considerably, but when she returned to her home she had a bad relapse. It appears that in the sanatorium she found a physician whom she regarded as a very charming man; he flattered her, and was always attentive to her; she responded to him, and she regarded herself as on close terms of friendship with him. When she left the sanatorium she wrote him a letter full of kind thoughts and good sentiments, to which she had no reply, and from that time her symptoms increased, for she then became convinced that she could no longer make an impression on other men. In her phantasies there was always the fear that she had lost the capacity of attraction for men. She had never put the matter to the test of experience, but she always complained of such fancies, especially as they were accompanied by sexual irritation, and these irritations gave her a new reason for feeling depressed. By this time she had built up a guilt complex, concerning which she was very reticent; she had spoken to no one about it except myself. Still, she always felt guilty about it. This guilt complex could feasibly have been the cause of her depression and her illness, but if it be closely examined, it is clear that it constituted an excellent tool for overcoming the husband. She was in a menacing mood, for she said, "I could betray my husband, because he has left me, because he does not now flatter me as he used to, and is not so attentive to me". In the logical sequence of events it is only one more stage to the betraying of the husband, and the actual breaking of the marriage tie. I have always found this breaking up of the marriage tie to be an act of revenge against the partner.
In other directions, too, there were further indications of her attitude to life. For instance, if she had a quarrel with her husband her feelings would be expressed. She dreamed once on these lines: "Once I was going shopping with my friend, and I met this physician but he did not want to greet me". I read this to mean that after this quarrel she had the desire to meet the physician. She held back, not because she was too chaste, or too modest, but only because she feared she could not make an impression on him. So, though she was a very beautiful woman, she had lost her self-confidence. Her whole demeanor shows that she feared defeats and rebuffs. There was, in fact, a feeling of great inferiority. She said, "I am only sure when I am with my parents or with similar people, when I feel this great warmth, this great love. I have been defeated by my husband, and now I have been defeated by the physician, so now I can only command in a restricted field, that is, in my family circle, where I can dominate my husband through my agoraphobia, and by means of my depression."
As time is short, I will conclude briefly. The development of such an attitude to life can be prevented. The best course is to begin in childhood, to avoid spoiling the child, and not to overlook deficiencies in various organs. The aim should be to make the child independent, to make him free, to give him enough self-confidence and courage. It would be my last word that every effort should be made to give such children enough courage to develop their social feelings, to be useful, and not to be terrified by the other sex, and if this could be done, there would be no more nervous adults.
If the patient has reached adult age, he must be reëducated and given a fresh start. The patients must be approached with affection; the attitude of the physician must be parental. They must be stirred to the depths of their personality; they require honest and frank handling and no demands should be made upon them; one should simply seek to strengthen their courage, so that later they may feel independent. In the treatment it is of the greatest importance to find out what mistake has been made in the past, to show what has been to blame for their neurotic attitude to life, to expose the connections between that attitude and the symptoms. The symptoms always fit the case. The nervous patient can be understood only if it be recognized that his behavior harmonizes with his symptoms. When he has been convinced about this, then his personality will change, and with the change will come a new determination towards life; his neurotic tendencies can then be said to have been cured.
Fuente: Alfred Adler, «The Cause and Prevention of Neuroses», The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology (Albany, N. Y.), vol. 23, n.º 1, abril-junio de 1928, págs. 4-11, en el volumen digitalizado por Google (ejemplar de la University of California) y publicado como dominio público en HathiTrust (uc1.b3802766). Se publicó antes en el Journal of Mental Science (Londres), 73 (1927), págs. 1-8, y, según la bibliografía, en la Internationale Zeitschrift für Individualpsychologie 5 (1927), págs. 245-252; esas versiones no se han cotejado. Transcripción a partir del texto (OCR) que ofrece HathiTrust página a página; la división en párrafos, que ese texto no conserva, se ha reconstruido y está pendiente de cotejo con las imágenes de página. Se corrigen los guiones de corte de línea y las rayas que el OCR da como guiones simples. Los comentarios p. n del código marcan el comienzo de cada página impresa.