The Motive of Crime
Dr. Alfred Adler Says that What the Criminal Really Desires Is to Demonstrate His Courage
By Ruth Benedict
ACROSS the ocean at noon each day a group of men and women, students of Individual Psychology and members of the famous Adler seminar, gather in the cozy study of Dr. Alfred Adler, their teacher, and discuss with him personal and pertinent topics.
“What about Hickman?”
The question broke in suddenly upon a discussion of the Inferiority Complex led by its discoverer and elucidator, Professor Adler of Vienna.
A group of ten persons was seated cozily in Dr. Adler’s study, with the eminent psychologist himself leaning back comfortably in his big leather armchair in front of his desk.
The informal nature of these noon gatherings is one of their charms. The class, if such it may be called, is a friendly meeting place for those eager to approach closer to the riddle of human relationships. Dr. Adler speaks without notes and appears at times rather to direct a conversation than to fulminate cut-and-dried principles. Many find that cigarettes aid the discussion. Whenever the professor is in Vienna he holds these noon causeries in English. They are open to all properly accredited persons, be they physicians or laity. The general principles of Individual Psychology are illustrated by the discussion of concrete cases, and questions from his hearers are always welcomed. Hence the query: “What about Hickman?” Details of the shocking crime had filled Austrian papers and members of the class, knowing that Dr. Adler had been especially interested in the Loeb boy’s mental attitude at the time of the former murder, felt sure that he had been following the present abnormal case.
“I cannot but believe that this crime was committed in emulation of other atrocities,” answered Dr. Adler gravely. “No doubt the murderer considered himself a dashing outlaw who wanted to outshine others, particularly young offenders.
“We have learned that every person must attain a goal of superiority in some way or other. Criminals achieve their purpose by doing something which the average person dares not attempt. They pit their courage against the world, especially against the police. Hickman had come up against the wall of his social inferiority and this was the way he took to get out.
“We see,” continued Dr. Adler, “since Hickman found himself in an unfavorable situation—he had lost his position in the bank, he was not succeeding brilliantly, not justifying the promise he had shown in school—he had to show himself superior in some way to satisfy this universal desire for preeminence, and so he took the usual cowardly way of attacking a weaker, unsuspecting person.”
“But how could society prevent this?” broke in an earnest social worker in the group. “Hickman had not been persecuted and on the other hand he had done nothing for which he could be punished.”
“No,” assented Dr. Adler, “and, anyway, I do not believe in punishment. It only makes a wrong-doer careful lest he be found out. It never reforms him. I think society’s error was in allowing this lad to think himself a hero. If we could educate the world, especially the children, to value correctly, so that they would understand the difference between being a hero and being a coward, then most crimes would be prevented.”
“But don’t you believe in capital punishment?” asked a conservative member of the group.
“No, because the more you increase punishment for such criminals the more you encourage them to feel that in undertaking crimes they are heroes fighting against great odds.”
[Box in the middle of the page:] “Punishment never reforms a criminal.” These words from the lips of one of the world’s greatest psychologists, Dr. Alfred Adler, should have some effect on public opinion in general and law-makers in particular.
It has a bearing also on household discipline. The whole conception of punishment seems destined to be weeded out of modern thought. It belongs to an age of barbarism, not an age of civilization.
Since what the bad boy wants is to prove himself brave, when you punish him you merely challenge him to more serious efforts to show you he is not afraid.
Source: Ruth Benedict, “The Motive of Crime. Dr. Alfred Adler Says that What the Criminal Really Desires Is to Demonstrate His Courage”, Psychology. Health, Happiness, Success (New York), vol. 10, April 1928, p. 25. Transcribed from the volume digitized by Google from the New York Public Library copy, HathiTrust nyp.33433005882885 (public domain, full view), scan 321; the OCR text was collated with the page image and the reading order of the three-column layout restored. The italic box set into the page is the magazine’s comment. “Hickman” is William Edward Hickman, whose kidnapping and murder of a twelve-year-old girl in Los Angeles in December 1927 was widely reported; “the Loeb boy” refers to the Leopold and Loeb murder of 1924.