Individual Psychology
By Alfred Adler, M.D., Vienna
SOMETIMES the correctness of this title has been doubted. But the opponents are entirely wrong. Particular knowledge already of this science and art can prove that our aim is to understand the individual style of life as a part of the whole. Therefore our subject involves at the same time the understanding of the whole, the life of mankind, connected with this poor earth-crust, and the social relation with the other sex. These three ties are inseparable and every human being answers in his individual attitude the questions growing out of these relations. These questions are inevitable. They must be established; i.e., in friendship, comradeship and social connection towards others and develop all those characteristics necessary to become a fellow man such as truth, responsibility, interest for the welfare of others and for the present and future of mankind. The second question demanded by the cosmic influence gives postulations for being useful, working, creating. As is easy to see, this question is deeply conditioned also by the social life and proves that “useful” means useful for society. Out of the relation between the two sexes originates the third call asking for the solution of the question of love and marriage. This question is also related to the first one, connected with the facts of a social life and with a view to the future—children!
Every individual is always answering the big and little questions in life. We can notice the answers and their varieties among different persons. And we can understand: the absolute truth lying in those questions, as in a mathematical problem, is never to be found out. We are not blessed with the knowledge of the last truth; we are only striving. So we are entangled in many mistakes and the answers given by every individual are involved and influenced by our lack of understanding. Mankind answered by creating our culture to solve the problems of life for the use of society. We feel and perceive the differences towards a right solution, and the efforts of everybody, the attitudes towards our social life are always gratifications, contradictions, accusations, pushing and dragging along the stream of our culture. Everybody is also perceiving and judging his own way and answer and strives to complete and to accomplish his own totality, always confronted, always asked and driven by the lasting gaping blanks between his individual solutions and the full completion of his life. We can understand that in this way there is always living and stimulating a feeling of inferiority.
This revealing of a common law in the human mind and psyche was the work of individual psychology. This science and art started in discovering during the first years the mental development of children affected with inherited or early established organic deficiencies. I could prove that children born with defective organs experience their bodies and its pains and weaknesses as a burden. They, much more than normal children, are striving to compensate those lacks and to arrive at a goal in which they are foreseeing and presuming a whole satisfaction, a feeling of superiority. In this stream going from “down” to “above”, from a felt minus to a presupposed plus, they are attacked much more by the difficulties of life and feel and live as though they were in an enemy country. They also develop all the movements, understanding, feeling, expressions and symptoms as a part of their answers to the questions of life. And they are fixing their style of life much more quickly and firmly to establish an offensive and defensive attitude. We can find strikingly expressed characteristics among those children. Fighting, hesitating, stopping, escaping, much more occupied with their own persons than with others they are therefore selfish, inconsiderate, lacking a social feeling, courage, and self-confidence because they fear a defeat more than they desire a success. Looking for favorable situations, they are inclined to create barriers to avoid the solution of the three questions of life. Then they are impressed by the dark side of life, burdened by the inferiority of their organs.
This same burden and pessimistic view originates when the environment is unfavorable. Therefore we find this great feeling of inferiority also among spoiled children. They are living in a symbiotic manner, like parasites, always connected with the mother. Their goal of superiority is to make this relationship permanent. Each change terrifies them. But changes are unavoidable. Because of this the usual feeling of inferiority is increased. In order to win the most favorable situation those children are always trying to occupy the mother and to give her tasks—in eating, in sleeping, in functioning. They do not like to go to sleep because they are then separated. They call for the mother and demand something more. In sleep they often cry or wet their beds to give signals of difficulty and trouble to the mother. When left alone they develop anxiety, an intelligent function, in order to be joined with the mother. Their social feeling is lacking in a high degree and only developed towards the mother. They consider other people enemies. Every new situation will be accepted as a danger. They are not prepared to have a new sister or brother and feel dethroned, become aggressive, peevish and reserved. In more difficult cases kindergarten, school, possible friends and comrades are considered enemies. Even the father can be looked upon as an opponent. They are inclined to exclude each new situation and person; always feeling themselves in danger they are lacking in courage and self-confidence. Later in life they are not adapted for occupation and love and marriage, because they consider only their own welfare and are not looking for the interests of others. The result is a hesitating attitude, in which they are stopping, or escaping from social life, occupation and love. They cannot overcome their great feeling of inferiority and strive to decrease the action circle of their life, domineering the family with their neurotic symptoms. Sometimes they turn towards crime, and in childhood these are the majority of the problem children.
The difficult problems appear when they lose their favorable situation. That is when they feel hated and notice more keenly the mistakes of the mother. Sometimes they connect with the over-indulgent father, but they are not able to have social contact with many people.
Nearly the same symptoms appear in hated children—that is: illegitimate or not wanted children. They feel curtailed and behave like enemies. They use their power only if they are stronger, sometimes in a cruel manner against weaker persons or animals. Their goal of superiority is to suppress the others. Their increased feeling of inferiority makes them suspicious and sly. It is difficult to win them and to develop social feeling and courage to do useful work.
The goal of superiority imagined by every person, more fixed and exalted in these three types, forms and moulds the unity of soul. In reality it must be in a concrete form—that is: to become a coachman, teacher, a physician, or priest, always directed towards the goal of superiority, of godlikeness. At this point it is understandable that poise, understanding, attitudes during the day and in sleep, every expression, symptom, emotion, and feeling is dependent upon this goal. Sexuality and all the sexual varieties and attitudes are also dominated by the style of life.
Children who are lacking in a social feeling and therefore in courage and self-confidence must be changed by their teachers. Adults who develop neurosis must have their courage increased by psychotherapists. In the future specialists must be created to establish the same faculties in criminals. The treatment and cure should be the right development of the double function of the mother: (1) to join with the person and to give the individual the experience of a trustworthy fellow-man; (2) to increase and spread the social feeling, to strengthen independence and courage.
A person who does not join with others, who does not have a true social feeling, is the one who stops, hesitates, fights, escapes when he comes in a new situation: such as kindergarten, school, marriage, friendship. All these are social situations and require social feeling. It is this type that become the criminals, problem children, neurotics and suicides. Striving for superiority and being lacking in courage they turn from the useful to the useless side. The following drawing illustrates the point:
[Drawing in the original. A vertical line rises from “Inferiority” at the bottom, beside which is written “Style of life formed in first 4 or 5 years”; at the point marked “new situation” it forks into a “useful action line” leading to “Superiority” and a “useless action line” leading to “Superiority on useless side”.]
A boy, 13 years old was sentenced to the detention home. He did poor work in school, stole and was a vagrant. Fortunately one of the teachers in the home was a pupil of mine. He investigated the boy's testimonies and discovered that until two years before the boy had done well in school. At that time the boy was put in a new class with a new teacher. The former teacher had been soft and kind and thus simulated the home atmosphere. The new teacher was hard and strict. The boy came into a new situation and was unable to cope with it. Further investigation showed that the boy had stolen in order to buy gifts for his school fellows. He wished to be the center of attention and to be appreciated, but not being able to cope with the situation adequately he sought for superiority on the useless side. An investigation in regard to his truancy showed that he ran away from home when he was beaten by his father. However in the night he would collect wood and lay it before his mother's door—his mother was a poor woman. This was a silent message to his mother “I love you, I want to be appreciated by you”. A spoiled child, he was joined to his mother in a symbiotic manner. He lacked social feeling towards others, naturally he could not attain superiority on the useful side in social situations. By tracing back in this boy's life to the point where he met his difficulty, by giving him the feeling of a fellow man and developing his social feeling this boy soon regained his courage and came back to a useful goal. Misunderstood and unguided this boy would doubtless have developed into a chronic criminal. Modern psychology and education must treat the causes and not the consequences.
The deeper insight into mind and psyche was perhaps, until the last fifty years, the work of intuition alone, not scientific, not teachable, and not learnable. Common sense ruled, and really in such a high degree that we must worship it as represented by poets, philosophers and educators. Outside of family tradition, the bible and fairy tales are our first teachers in understanding human nature. Homer, Shakespeare, Dostojewski and others are reaching upwards in their understanding of the complications of human life. Socrates and his Stoical School, like individual psychology, insisted that everything in the mind was dependent upon how the individual looked upon it; Kant, Montagne, LaRochefoucauld, William James and others had the deepest insight into the soul of human beings.
The development of the science of psychology began with the consideration of the abnormal expressions of the psyche. Perceptible scientific points of view lie in the theories of hypnotism as taught in the School of Nancy. Charcot pierced the wall and opened the great field for inquiries into the nervous symptoms diminished or increased by hypnosis. Janet developed a great and astonishing work regarding the reciprocal influence between body and psyche. He also saw the weakness of neurotic persons expressed sometimes in a “sentiment d'incomplitude”. Breuer (Vienna) found, as he wrote to me in a letter, “the sparkling stone lying on the road”, describing the importance of suppressed experiences. Freud continued this idea and reduced all the expressions of life, of the human being and mankind, to a suppressed and unconscious sexual desire, the “Oedipus Complex”. In the last fifteen years there has been much more inquiry into the influences of the ego and the desire for death. I myself have emphasized the unity of the style of life which is always fixed and established by the ruling actions line, the real creative power in life, a part of life itself beginning with a feeling of inferiority and continually striving toward a goal of totality, of superiority. This goal dominates the innate possibilities and gives the answers to the questions of life in each individual solution. The superstition of inherited powers and mistakes was done away with—the human being became the master of his life. But in the individual the wrong and mistaken style of life, built up in early childhood, brings up aggravated conflicts connected with the hesitating attitude towards new situations and decisions. This hesitation, stopping or escaping from the questions of life, conditions the three remarkable mistaken forms of life: wrong characteristics (problem children and adults), neurosis, crimes. Jung's attitude, closely connected with the Freudian psychoanalysis, takes for granted more than his teacher the inherited qualities in the introverted and extraverted types. The former, more occupied with his own person, and the latter, connected with the environment, are described by individual psychology not as a beginning but as the results of a varied degree of courage and social feeling. We must insist upon the same difference in regard to his “innate” types of intellectual feeling, acting, and intuitive life. And the social unconsciousness is no other than the social feeling, only that we cannot agree with the great importance given to the difference between consciousness and unconsciousness. Then too, the conscious is no more and no better understood than the unconscious, but the degree of their development is formed by the demands of the goal of superiority.
The nearest to the individual psychologists, and really their predecessors, are among the Americans—William James and Stanley Hall. The latter completely accepted individual psychology in the last years of his fruitful life. Watson in his more mechanical views clearly presupposes the conditions of the goal of superiority and the striving of the mind and psyche. McDougall in his specialized inquiries into the 14 instincts could easily combine all these movements in the feeling of inferiority and its compensations and in social feeling.
The great and worthwhile efforts of mental hygiene in America approach the lines and purposes of individual psychology. The great importance of the feeling of inferiority especially is clearly recognized by all serious authors. On this path the great progresses in education and understanding of the psyche are made. The mistakes made in the family, due to the lacks in courage and social feeling, as the driving factors in the development of problem children, are well known and a great number of men and women are trying to teach the parents and the children.
Individual psychology has recognized that the problems begin before or in a new situation for which a child or adult is not prepared. His style of life fixed after the third or fourth year does not agree with the existing social laws of these situations, i.e.: kindergarten, school, society, occupation, love, marriage, old age, etc. The greater feeling of inferiority (among organically defective, spoiled or hated children) strives to exclude social connections because of the strongly developed selfishness. Under these circumstances we notice all the deviations as difficulties, neurosis, crimes. The only rescue and preservation lie in courage and social feeling.
The parents therefore must learn to lessen the family egoism and to put the children in a social environment as soon as possible. Their courage and independence must not be hindered by pampering and continued support. Quarrels in the family can be prevented if the parents do not rule but treat the children in a friendly manner. And both, parents and children, have to perceive that the personal and common happiness are dependent upon the interest of each in the other. In this striving is included usefulness for society, all good characteristics and the right preparation for new situations.
The mistakes made in the family must be recognized early. Psychotherapists, psychologists, social workers, and especially the teachers must understand how to correct them. The pillar of modern psychology and education on which we must lean must eventually be the school. We cannot single out each difficult child; often it is too late. The teacher of the future will not only recognize and criticize the lacks and mistakes but he will join with the parents and modern psychologists in leading youth to a hopeful future in which their social feeling and responsibility will increase.
Source: Alfred Adler, “Individual Psychology”, The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology (Albany, N.Y.: Boyd Printing Co.) 22 (1927), No. 2, July–September 1927, pp. 116–122 (DOI 10.1037/h0072190). Transcribed from the volume digitized by Google from the University of California copy, HathiTrust uc1.b3802765 (public domain, full view), scans 138–144; the OCR text was collated with the page images. Spelling and punctuation of the print are kept (e.g. “Dostojewski”, “Montagne”, “sentiment d'incomplitude”); a comma before “Psychotherapists” (p. 122) has been read as a full stop. The hand-drawn diagram on p. 119 is described in brackets.