Alfred Adler—Apostle of Individual and Social Psychology
An Interview with One of Europe’s Greatest Psychologists
by Eleanore Carey
VERY recently to our shores on the great ship Belgenland has come a great man. It is his first trip to America, and quite naturally New York would be his first stop. He thinks New York is a wonderful breathing, palpitating place. “It seems to be so very much alive,” he said, “with its millions of people moving hurriedly from place to place.” And we have been so kindly disposed to him! I wondered by what process that particular impression should have taken form in his consciousness—we who so eagerly await the message he has to give us.
Dr. Alfred Adler, of Vienna, one of the triumvirate of Freud, Jung and Adler, the “Big Three” in Psychology, is a mild-mannered, soft-spoken gentleman. In spite of the many urgent demands upon his time he can still be the very charming, polite gentleman. I was amazed after talking with him for quite a time (which in itself was unusual, for many of our prominent men haven’t time at all) to hear, in a very mild voice, “Please, may I go now—it seems someone has been waiting to see me this long time!”
With a soft-spoken apology assuring me of his regret at having to leave he went to his other appointment. I am sure this attribute of considerate thoughtfulness is partly the reason of his success.
Individual Psychology! “The science of human nature and the art of understanding. The basis of this art is the fundamental idea of the feeling of inferiority and the striving of life. Every expression and symptom is a detail belonging to the great ‘action line’, or ‘behavior pattern,’ leading one from inferiority to a goal of superiority.”
[Caption:] Alfred Adler, one of Europe’s Triumvirate of Psychological Science, who is visiting the United States. —Underwood and Underwood
In this country we have learned to regard Psychology as analysis of our subconscious, or deeper self—and by being analyzed we have been able to reach that subconscious and drive from its “holdings” the repressions that have chained us to certain fears, unpleasant habits—and which have often affected our physical as well as our mental well-being.
It is a bit surprising, then, to learn that neither Dr. Sigmund Freud nor Dr. Alfred Adler, has ever been psychoanalyzed! Dr. Adler says:
“I am not a follower of analysis and I have the same thoughts as every scientific opponent who does not agree with a certain science. Analysis is merely treatment—or, call it what you will—and an understanding. The Freudian analysis is not necessary. Individual Psychology realizes the importance of making a person realize his own style of life. It is a great adventure. It is a newer psychology, has a different basis, one which is termed Social Psychology.
“The real reason for a neurosis is a lack of social feeling—not in sexuality. But still the sex development is built up upon the development of social feeling! The whole reason for Psychology at all is an understanding of our own selves, but human beings are tied because of social relationship, for our understanding is always dependent upon our connections with society.”
There are three great questions of life to solve—first, social feeling, or one’s relationship to life; second, one’s occupation, or one’s daily pursuits; third, love—in all its forms. And there seems to be in Dr. Adler’s mind the possibility of a fourth, which is Art.
With many people nowadays the effect of the life they lead or have led and their misunderstandings, has brought about a neurosis. And Dr. Adler, when asked for a definition of a neurotic, said: “A neurotic is a human being who is making a perfectly correct reaction to a bad environment—but the bad environment is not necessarily bad, only the person’s misinterpretation, often dating from childhood, of the actual facts.
“What Individual Psychology does is to rectify the patient’s error of interpretation and to give him fresh courage to continue the race from ‘scratch.’”
As a pine tree growing in a beautiful valley, with fertile soil clustering around its roots and the tall trunk and bright green of its needles, has the air of majesty and self-assuredness, just so the little struggling pine on the top of the mountain peak, with rocks and dry gravel for its footing, shows clearly the development attained thru social condition and environment. It is only when the patient understands that he, like the pine tree on the rocks, is making a perfectly natural, correct reaction to environment that his mental twist can be straightened out.
“Supression or repression is not the fundamental of a neurosis. In childhood,” continued Dr. Adler, “most children make an ideal picture of life—according to their surroundings, then try to live up to it. The feeling of inferiority is nourished and accentuated by the petting and humoring and adulation of their adult companions.
“Lust of domination or hardness in the parent can terrify children to such an extent that they harbor distrust, and they often misinterpret the lives of their partners in marriage or their friends thruout their life on earth. Also it may fill them with a sharpened need of ‘warmth’ which will never receive satiation in this world, unfitting them perhaps for the responsibilities akin to the marriage relationship, or the raising of children, because they have lost their belief in themselves.
“The man, thru a long outworn common tradition, possesses a slight advantage which he attempts to preserve selfishly, but to his own detriment. And in sharing this view it would be well to bring to his mind the fact that in these days the master of the family is a thing of the past.” Polygamy, perversions and sexual vagrancies can be explained if one takes into consideration the fear of the “morally low” to stand up before the other sex.
“The idea that marriage is sort of a cure-all, a reformer, and the one remedy for lax morality, drunkenness, gambling, and all the general ills that flesh is heir to, is prevalent in the civilized world today. Love and marriage are not remedies. In most cases one only creates new injuries without removing the old. The same error prevails in regard to the curative power of pregnancy. The marriage question, like all other problems of life, must be answered out of strength not out of weakness.
“To be a true fellow-man!” Dr. Adler propose[s] this formula. The goal of marriage and the imperatives which make one “to be a true fellow-man say, at least, to make oneself useful; to thin[k] more of the other than of oneself; to make th[e] other’s life easier and more beautiful.”
But how is one to be a “true fellow-man?” Physical and intellectual qualifications can [b]e omitted as a matter of course, but not so the “maturity of the soul.” Dr. Adler says that in spi[te] of all our efforts things are badly ordered for “th[e] soul in human society.” And in Individual Ps[y]chology Dr. Adler believes he has found the re[a]son—“abundantly.”
“Most men begin with a false start. An all-to[o] great inferiority complex, compelling them to u[se] egotistical, demonstrative forms of expression, [in] which they think to find their will to mastery. [Or] else they give themselves up to pessimism witho[ut] action, under the pressure of which they move [as] if under the effect of brakes. Arrogance from [a] feeling of weakness, or despondency thru am[bi]tion, marks their way. At best they are proper[ly] prepared for a lonely life, but never for life w[ith] one companion, or for life in society. Whoe[ver] falls in their way is their chosen object. Th[ey] must be wrecked in marriage, since th[ey] lack the spiritual organs for social existence.”
But “marriage as a task aims at the right ord[er]ing of the claims of community, of vocation, a[nd] of eroticism!”
This new angle of Psychology interested me vitally, and I made numerous inquiries as to how one might find out more about it. Whereupon Dr. Adler introduced me to a very attractive, young physician, Dr. Walter B. Wolfe. This man is Dr. Adler’s only American representative. Dr. Wolfe has been at the great man’s side for over a year, in Vienna, and is remaining in this country to carry on the good work here. Dr. Wolfe has also to his credit a book, which is to be published this spring—The Nervous Child—which contains the chief fundamentals along the line of prevention which is a great part of the Adlerian Psychology. He has also distinguished himself considerably by the translations he has made of Dr. Adler’s books into the English language.
I was informed of the feeling of affection the people in Vienna have toward Dr. Adler. Of how he has worked long and late in his effort to change the poor sections of that city by instructing the teachers and the parents. There is rarely a night which passes but one can find Dr. Adler teaching or lecturing some place in his native city, telling his people of the great, inestimable value of Individual Psychology. And in much the same manner as the Chinese doctors thru ages past, he points out to them the greater importance of prevention rather than that of curing. He tells one how to find normal health, happiness, and prosperity, just as the Chinese doctors were paid to keep their patients well, rather than to find the necessity of curing them.
Many Psychologists apparently hold their knowledge or science as meant for them alone or their particular private group—but Dr. Adler feels that his message of Individual Psychology belongs to the people for the good of mankind. His gentleness, his refinement and sensitiveness of manner—his consideration for the welfare of the other fellow—his willingness to give, and give unrestainedly, of himself and his time, proves quite conclusively that at least one human being on earth has found just how “to be a true fellow-man.”
Source: Eleanore Carey, “Alfred Adler—Apostle of Individual and Social Psychology. An Interview with One of Europe’s Greatest Psychologists”, Psychology. Health, Happiness, Success (New York), vol. 8, February 1927, pp. 37–38, continued on p. 70; with a photograph by Underwood and Underwood. Transcribed from the volume digitized by Google from the New York Public Library copy, HathiTrust nyp.33433006419851 (public domain, full view), scans 141–142 and 174; the OCR text was collated with the page images. On p. 38 the right edge of the second column is cut off in the scan: the letters lost at the ends of the lines are supplied in square brackets. Spelling of the print kept (“thru”, “Supression”, “unrestainedly”). The magazine article gives Adler’s statements between quotation marks; the rest is the interviewer’s paraphrase.